Miller Research was tasked with conducting a study on instances of community resilience in Wales on behalf of the Building Communities Trust (BCT). The primary objective of the project was to develop qualitative case studies that complement an emerging index of community resilience in Wales. By exploring the connection between the index findings and the lived experiences of individuals in different geographical contexts, the study aimed to provide valuable insights for policy discussions on the role of place and community in fostering resilience.
The BCT is a Wales-wide third sector organisation that supports people and communities to develop solutions to local issues, improve wellbeing, realise aspirations, and build stronger communities in disadvantaged localities.
Background to the WCAI
The Wales Community Assets Index (WCAI) has been designed to gauge the challenges faced by different areas, including insufficient community and civic infrastructure, relative isolation, and low participation levels. This index, applied at the Middle Layer Super Output Areas (MSOAs) level, comprises three domains:
- Civic Assets: Assesses the existence of crucial community, civic, educational, and cultural assets in the area and nearby locations.
- Connectedness: Evaluates connectivity to essential services, digital infrastructure, levels of isolation, and the strength of the local job market.
- Active and Engaged Community: Focuses on measuring civic and community activity within the third sector, while also identifying barriers to participation and engagement.
The index combines scores from these domains with the Welsh Index of Multiple Deprivation (WIMD) to form the Welsh Community Resilience Index (WCRI). Areas ranking in the top 25% in Wales on the combined WCAI and WIMD 2019 are labelled as ‘less resilient’ areas, indicating both high levels of deprivation and challenges in social infrastructure. In total, there are 102 communities classified as ‘Less Resilient’ Areas (LRA) across Wales.
The WCRI builds upon similar work carried out in England by Local Trust and OCSI, related to Left behind? Understanding Communities on the edge. The research revealed that deprived communities experience significant social and economic disparities when lacking places for social interaction (such as community centres, pubs, or village halls), an active and engaged community, and adequate connectivity to the broader economy (both physically and digitally). Areas with these deficiencies tend to exhibit higher rates of unemployment, ill health, and child poverty compared to other areas with similar socio-economic characteristics.
Our Research
In collaboration with BCT, we chose four specific areas as case studies to gain valuable insights into the resilience dynamics within these communities: Penrhiwceiber, Cardigan & Aberporth, Duffryn & Maesglas, and South Riverside. We utilised various forms of engagement, such as interviews, workshops, and on-site visits, in each case study area to interact with community members and local organisations.
The engagement activities were centred on assessing the range, scale, and accessibility of community assets across different areas in Wales. We aimed to understand how these services assist individuals in crisis mitigation, their contribution to maintaining community well-being, and the examination of specific factors like fuel poverty and the cost of living within the case study areas.
Upon concluding the project, we compiled a report for BCT summarising the case study findings. This report will not only complement the index but also serve as a foundation for critiquing and improving the quantitative measures and indicators moving forward.
The full report from BCT can be found here.